[Daanz-dip] This has happened before folks

[CanberraDoug]

Greg

Complain about Sean as much as you like, but you created the situation stirring all the disputes by the insistence on proposing a divisive decision in preventing under 16's from competing in tournament, but demanding it be affiliated by DAANZ or you wouldn't continue.

The demand was inappropriate and remains so.

I fully support Sean's stance on this issue.
Sometimes principles need to be enforced.

On a couple of other points....
  1.. Jason Whitby stated "Does anyone else remember the time that
  Andrew Geraghty was President of the DAA".
  Andrew was NEVER President, he was Secretary.
  2.. Greg Evans stated "Unfortunately, I think that under this president things are going to get worse before they get better.  Once he's won his beloved Bismark Cup ..."
  I believe this was supposed to be a reference to Sean (being in the running for the Bismark Cup) who is/was Secretary NOT President.
Please get your facts right guys.

Doug

----- Original Message ----- 
From: Greg Evans 
To: DAANZ-dip Email Discussion Group for Diplomacy in Australia & NewZealand 
Sent: Friday, September 15, 2006 11:06 PM
Subject: Re: [Daanz-dip] This has happened before folks


> If Sean has disappeared from the hobby, that is a loss in my opinion.

Sean has not disappeared form the hobby.  I'd say he has stood down as 
secretary so as to raise the dispute against the executive without 
generating a conflict of interest - which in my humble opinion was the right 
thing to do if he was insistant on raising the dispute (though I still wish 
he didnt !).

I respect Sean for being passionate about diplomacy and for his loyalty to 
his kids.  He has been to EVERY tournament this year and I dont expect that 
he will stop now.  He's in with an excellent chance of winning the Bismark, 
so (as appalled as he is on the age restriction issue) I'd even expect him 
to show up at an affiliated GongCon if it were to go ahead.  He is one of 
the players who IS highly motivated by the Bismark and will travel long 
distances to attend a tournament based purely on its affiliation.

The amount of effort he has put into the hobby has never been questioned. 
Whether that effort has been appreciated or misdirected, however, is 
debatable.  He has good intentions and sincerely believes he is doing the 
right thing. However, his methods and attitude toward people that dont share 
his 'vision' is intolerant at best - intolerable at worst.  He rubs a LOT of 
people (including this black duck) the wrong way.  I sincerely hope that in 
future he can find a more constructive, open minded and tolerant way to 
direct his energies in the hobby for the sake of everyone involved.  Cooling 
off and withdrawing the dispute would be a good start....but I wont be 
holding my breath.

Live and let live I say.  If we are doing things right, we should not be 
losing ANYBODY from the hobby. 
_______________________________________________
Daanz-dip mailing list
Daanz-dip at daanz.org.au
http://www.daanz.org.au/mailman/listinfo/daanz-dip
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://www.daanz.org.au/pipermail/daanz-dip/attachments/20060915/557a37f8/attachment.html